status of the TrNNs_ART webSite
Table of Contents
-
Home TrNN&ART Status:
-
Questions: Grossberg's c-ART, Transformer NNs, and consciousness?
-
For whom the bell tolls
-
Grossberg part of webSite
-
Grossbergs ART- Adaptive Resonance Theory
-
Grossbergs cellular patterns computing
-
Grossbergs complementary computing
-
Grossbergs Consciousness: neural [architecture, function, process, percept, learn, etc]
-
Grossbergs cooperative-competitive
-
Grossbergs [core, fun, strange] concepts
-
Grossbergs equations of the mind
-
Grossbergs laminar
-
Grossbergs list of [chapter, section]s
-
Grossbergs list of [figure, table]s
-
Grossbergs list of index
-
Grossbergs modal architectures
-
Grossbergs modules (microcircuits)
-
Grossbergs overview
-
Grossbergs paleontology
-
Grossbergs quoted text
-
Grossbergs what is consciousness
-
TrNNs have incipient consciousness
-
Introduction
-
Let the machines speak
-
machine consciousness, the need
-
non-conscious themes notes
-
opinions- Blake Lemoine, others
-
Pribram 1993 quantum fields and consciousness proceedings
-
references- Grossberg
-
references- non-Grossberg
-
reader Howell notes
-
Taylors consciousness
-
TrNN controls need consciousness
-
TrNNS&ART theme
-
TrNNs augment by cART
-
TrNNs have incipient consciousness
-
[use, modfication]s of c-ART
-
What is consciousness: from historical to Grossberg
-
why is cART unknown
Home TrNN&ART Status:
26Oct2023 ready to blog on Connectionists...
- mostly finished porting [small, core] part of my "webSite management system" from QNial programming to Linux bash. There is enormous room for [additiona port, extension, improvement]s.
- "lost images" were again screen captured
- sidebar nomenclature added to 2 captioned images, should do more, plus improve image-text formatting (not the captions - text appearing in the image)
- several links to [image, webPage]s were fixed
- Menu for TrNNs_ART [revamp, linkCheck]ed - especially "family of ART" etc
- none of the webPages are complete, but some of them give at least a flavor of what is currently planned
27Sep2023 After 2 months of rewriting my webSite management system, I was able to upload my webSite content with "relatively reliable links", although there is some work to do to improve it further (pehaps in 3-6 months).
31Aug2023 I try to maintain notes of work that I am doing on [computer software, projects], to make it easier to get back into a project after a break of [month, year]s, and to be able to see how I solved problems in the past very handy more often that I would expect). For the TrNNs_ART project, some of the "notes files: are :
- "$d_web"'ProjMini/TrNNs_ART/0_TrNNS_ART notes.txt' - main set of notes for this project
- "$d_SysMaint"'images/0_image notes.txt' - notes from recent bash script work. This has NOT been uploaded yet.
-
However, I haven't updated most of my website other than this TrNNs_ART project subWebSite, and trying to find the time to rewrite my web management software and to update stylistic changes to webPages may take another year or so...
31Aug2023 Priorities
- recently done: bash script to convert webPage lists to captions for images - mmostly done for now. ~5% of the captioned images (~620 total) have issues, but that will have to wait.
-
- mid-Sep2023: post my question to Connectionists - this is hugely delayed while I get a minimum of background information ready.
10May2023 This "Trnns&ART" webSite is in a very early stage of development. Many webPages have little or no content yet, and are "ghosted grey" in the menus at the top of each webPage.
10Apr2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Captioned images [image, link] problems :
26Oct2023
- finished porting core part of my "webSite management system" from QNial programming to Linux bash.
- "lost images" were again screen captured
- sidebar nomenclature added to 2 captioned images, should do more, plus improve image-text formatting (not the captions - text appearing in the image)
- several links to [image, webPage]s were fixed
- Menu for TrNNs_ART [revamp, linkCheck]ed - especially "family of ART" etc
- none of the webPages are complete, but some of them give at least a flavor of what is currently planned
29Sep2023 Here is a list of various problems with the captioned images and their links on the webPage Grossbergs list of [figure, table]s.html :
I went through All /images- captioned/ :
no permission clause
no permission clause :
p398fig11.37 Simulation of the no swap baseline condition (Logothetis, Leopold, Sheinberg 1996).png
caption cut off :
28 images :
cover page - create normal caption
02.12 line?
04.53 char?
05.07 char?
05.13 char
07.07 char
08.07 char
08.15 char
09.17 word
11.37 word
11.38 word
11.39 word
12.23 char
12.61 char
13.08 line
13.13 line
13.16 char
13.17 word
13.19 char
13.20 word
13.22 char
13.40 word
13.42 word
13.43 char
14.03 cut off bottom
15.09 char
16.45 word
17.01 word
image-caption is way too tall :
20 images : mostly that the blank space at the bottom is too tall
12.[02, 23, 33, 36, 39, 44, 56, 65]
13.[08, 13, 20, 22]
14.04
15.21
16.[16, 35, 40]
keep normal caption at bottom, move acronyms to right side :
09.16, 14.02, 14.08
Go through image number sequence for missing images
2 images : Go through image number sequence for missing images
05.45
13.32
no link in webPage!
p431fig12.27 Howell - reminds me of Jose Principe etal's SpikingNN implementation of Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Space (RKHS)
there is a link for p546fig15.13, but separate bullets appear for :
p546fig15.13... The total learned response is a sum R of all the doubly
p546fig15.13 Howell: Sounds like (a) random recurrent nets
p505fig13.32 Behavioral contrast: [response suppression, antagonist rebound] both calibrated by shock levels.png
missing 'subsequent links' in the same html paragraph
It appears that my functions fail to capture "subsequent links".
This will require modifications of link [search, replace].
Questions: Grossberg's c-ART, Transformer NNs, and consciousness?
ART assess theories of consciousness
10Aug2023 I haven't yet provided content for this webPage. I don't expect to able to before Feb2024.
10May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
ART augmentation of other research
10May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
[definitions, models] of consciousness
10Aug2023 This subWebSite will still be updated from time to time, but as my objective was to provide a quick listing from wikipedia and other "popular sources", with [link, commentary, relative [feature, strength, weakness]s], I won't go into much further detail. One exception is the theme of "quantum consciousness", because that theme was brought up by a contact and my own low interest did need to be revisited.
12Apr2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
For whom the bell tolls
10Aug2023 I haven't revisited this issue since creating an empty webPage, but I certainly intend to get back to it and look for good commentaries.
11May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossberg part of webSite
10Aug2023 This "Grossberg" subWebSite is still in a very early stage of development, and is where almost all of my time has been put to date. I will add more material as my own work progresses, but slowly over a couple of years at least. As with all of my projects, there is no expectation that I will "finish", rather that work will only continue as I can afford the time, and will peter out as other priorities take over.
I have minimized my own commentary, as I prefer to provide [commentary, [figure, table], caption, quotes]s from Grossberg's "Conscious Mind, Resonant Brain" book. That will hopefully be better for the reader, and provide at least some reference material as
This "Grossberg" subWebSite is much larger than the rest of my TrNNS_ART webSite
07May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs ART- Adaptive Resonance Theory
31Aug2023 Howell: My intent was to eventually develop this webPage as am overview to how to [build, apply] ART, but I'm not sure I will get around to this for 1-5 years.
11May2023 Howell: This webPage is only just being drafted. It will be delayed as my current focus is shifting to "cART&TrNNs".
Grossbergs cellular patterns computing
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
10May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs complementary computing
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
10May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs Consciousness: neural [architecture, function, process, percept, learn, etc]
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
Grossbergs cooperative-competitive
1May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
10Apr2023, initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs [core, fun, strange] concepts
31Aug2023 These thematic searches will be updated as I read through the book, and work on related projects. The bash script file could also use improvement.
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
??May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs equations of the mind
31Aug2023 initial, first posted] : I lost previous content for this item.
Grossbergs laminar
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
10Apr2023, initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs list of [chapter, section]s
10Aug2023 I haven't yet provided content for this webPage.
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
Grossbergs list of [figure, table]s
28Sep2023 Status of the [html, png] captioned images from the book : Stephen Grossberg 2021 "Conscious Mind, Resonant Brain"
Purpose of publicly posting the images :
- helpful to readers : I have done all of this work so that I can easily view multiple [images, html versions of captions] at a time as I go through themes in the book. This may be handy for others who have who have bought the book.
- helpful to buyers : The captioned images, along with the webPages related directly to the book, may provide a very detailed context to help those not familiar with Grossberg's work, as an encouragement to buying it. The images alone really do require a person to have the book in order to properly understand them.
- diffusion of Grossberg's work into [presentations, papers, books, courses] of others : The public posting of the images would facilitate this, providing additional profile for Grossberg's work.
Issues with a few of the images :
- mid-quality images : screen-captures of the Kindle version of Grossberg's book are noticeably lower resolution than those in the book. On the other hand, readers may see that as another reason for purchasing the hardcover edition? At any rate, I personally much prefer to read the hardcover version.
- missing images : At present, the images listed in the section "Missing captions" below will have to wait a couple of months until I can get back to work on them, as well as some failed links in my webPages.
- spelling, typos : I have many corrections to make, but my intent is to improve caption formatting first, over the next 3-6 months.
10Aug2023 I haven't yet provided content for this webPage, but image captions are complete, albeit with [spelling, format, content issues] that I intend to fix in 3-6 months time, after working on other webSite content.
13May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs list of index
?May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs modal architectures
11May2023 Howell: This webPage is only just being drafted. It is not a core priority (related to the 3 questions of the overview), so progress will be slow.
?May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs modules (microcircuits)
11May2023 Howell: This webPage is only just being drafted. It is not a core priority (related to the 3 questions of the overview), so progress will be slow.
07May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs overview
10Aug2023 Perhaps 30-50% of this webPage has been started, but it will likely be only after Feb2024 before I can get back to it given other priorities.
19Apr2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs paleontology
10Apr2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs quoted text
19Jul2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Grossbergs what is consciousness
?date? initial draft, ?date? initial posting
TrNNs have incipient consciousness
10Aug2023 I haven't really started to put this together, and it may take many months to find the time. I've also spent considerable time looking for reports I did for a social media project at work in 2020-2012 period, but no luck so far.
10Apr2023, initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Introduction
10Aug2023 This webPage is far enough advanced that I won't be working on it for many months until I am able to complete many other webPages that have little to no content.
?May2023? I lost track of when the webPage was initially created.
Let the machines speak
07May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
machine consciousness, the need
10Aug2023 I haven't really started to put this together, and it may take many months to find the time. I've also spent considerable time looking for reports I did for a social media project at work in 2020-2012 period, but no luck so far.
22Apr2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
non-conscious themes notes
~30May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
opinions- Blake Lemoine, others
10Apr2023, initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Pribram 1993 quantum fields and consciousness proceedings
25Jul2023 initial draft, 30Aug2023? initial posting
references- Grossberg
10Aug2023 I haven't yet provided content for this webPage.
25Apr2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
references- non-Grossberg
25Apr2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
reader Howell notes
16May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
Taylors consciousness
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities.
10May2023 There is almost nothing on this webPage yet...
10Apr2023, initial draft, ?date? initial posting
TrNN controls need consciousness
10Aug2023 I haven't yet provided content for this webPage. It does touch on one of three questions of this webSite as mentioned in the Introduction :
- Are current (semi-manual) "controls" of "Large Language Models (LLMs) going in the direction of machine consciousness, without those involved being aware of this? Will "controls" ultimately require machine consciousness as one of their components, in particular for [learning, evolution] in a stable and robust manner?
10May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
TrNNS&ART theme
10Aug2023 This subWebSite is still in a very early stage of development, but it is important to the questions relating Transformer Neural Networks (TrNNs) and Grossberg's cART-related architectures. I have NOT yet even started on actual software programming of either [TrNNs, cART], and that may delayed by 6 months or so as I have higher-priority work to do on related lower-level Spiking Neural Network (SNN) [architesture, finction, process, operating system]s.
The primary questions are :
- Do "Large Language Models (LLMs) (such as chatGPT, LaMDA, etc) already exhibit a [protero, incipient] consciousness, in particular given the rough similarity of the basic unit of "Transformer Neural Networks" (TrNNs) to one of Grossberg's general "modules". The latter are proposed as a small number of units that are readily recombined with slight modifications as a basis for much of brain architecture, much like the small number of concepts in physics can be applied across a broad range of themes?
- How difficult would it be to augment "Transformer Neural Networks" (TrNNs) with Grossberg's [concept, architecture]s, including the emergent systems for consciousness? Perhaps this would combine the scalability of the former with the [robust, extendable] foundations of the latter, which is supported by [broad, diverse, deep] data from [neuroscience, psychology], as well success in real world advanced [science, engineering] applications?
- Are current (semi-manual) "controls" of "Large Language Models (LLMs) going in the direction of machine consciousness, without those involved being aware of this? Will "controls" ultimately require machine consciousness as one of their components, in particular for [learning, evolution] in a stable and robust manner?
07May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
TrNNs augment by cART
10Aug2023 This webPage has not yet been worked on. It will touch on one of three questions of this webSite as mentioned in the Introduction :
10May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
TrNNs have incipient consciousness
10Aug2023 I haven't yet provided content for this webPage. It does touch on one of three questions of this webSite as mentioned in the Introduction :
- Do "Large Language Models (LLMs) (such as chatGPT, LaMDA, etc) already exhibit a [protero, incipient] consciousness, in particular given the rough similarity of the basic unit of "Transformer Neural Networks" (TrNNs) to one of Grossberg's general "modules". The latter are proposed as a small number of units that are readily recombined with slight modifications as a basis for much of brain architecture, much like the small number of concepts in physics can be applied across a broad range of themes?
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focus on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by others.
[use, modfication]s of c-ART
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focuss on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by other.
11May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
What is consciousness: from historical to Grossberg
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focuss on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by other.
??May or Jul??2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting
why is cART unknown
11May2023 Howell: This webPage won't be drafted for a few months, given the need to focuss on project priorities, and my sense that it's best to apply the concepts myself to get a feel for the subject. Or better yet, to search from related comments by other.
11May2023 initial draft, ?date? initial posting