/*+-----+ From Lucas's book : 10Jan2017 corrections p68h0.0 Equation (4-16), with my more up-to-date symbols, and removing redundant "c"'s (and using BT = B0 + BI, but B0 = 0) : /%(4-16) ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)/c*Rpcs(POIo(t),t)*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART)*Vons(PART)/Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^5*[Rpcs(POIo(t),t)*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) - Vons(PART)*t] - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) } = Vons(PART)/c*Rpcs(POIo(t),t)*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART)*Vons(PART)/Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^5*Rpcs(POIo(t),t)*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) - 3*Q(PART)*Vons(PART)/Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^5*Vons(PART)*t - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) } = Vons(PART)/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART)*Vons(PART) *cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))/Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 - 3*Q(PART)*Vons(PART)^2*t /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^4 - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)] } = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART)*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 - 3*Q(PART)*Vons(PART) *t/Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^4 - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART) } = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 - 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *Vons(PART) *t/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *[1 - Vons(PART)*t/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) ] - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } Summarizing : (1) ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART)/Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *[1 - Vons(PART)*t/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) ] - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } /*+--+ 15&16May2016 But looking at : /% Vons(PART) *t/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) From "Rθ0pcs(POIo(t),t)", RFo basis : (1)* Rθ0pcs(POIo(t),t) = Rocs(POIo)*cos(Aθoc(POIo)) - Vons(PART)*t From "Rθ0pcs(POIo(t),t)", RFp basis (1)** Rθ0pcs(POIo(t),t) = Rpcs(POIo(t),t)*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) combining (1)* & (1)** : Rocs(POIo)*cos(Aθoc(POIo)) - Vons(PART)*t = Rpcs(POIo(t),t)*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) So : Vons(PART)*t = Rocs(POIo)*cos(Aθoc(POIo)) - Rpcs(POIo(t),t)*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) or : Vons(PART)*t/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) = Rocs(POIo)*cos(Aθoc(POIo))/Rpcs(POIo(t),t)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) - 1 (2) = Rθ0ocs(POIo)/Rθ0pcs(POIo(t),t) - 1 Subbing (2) into (1) : (1) ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *[1 - Vons(PART)*t/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) ] - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *[ 1 - Rθ0ocs(POIo)/Rθ0pcs(POIo(t),t) - 1 ] - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } Summarizing : (3) ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *Rθ0ocs(POIo)/Rθ0pcs(POIo(t),t) - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } /********************* Compare this to : /********************* >>>>>>>>> ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] without use of Lenz's Induction Law (need to RE-CHECK!!!) /*Howell's expression Section "∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] without use of Lenz's Induction Law (need to RE-CHECK!!!)" /%(6)* ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))^2*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 11Jan2017 WRONG UNITS!!! - EIpds(POIo(t),t)/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } /*While the factor of 3 IS EXPLAINED, this is NOT the same as (3) in the sub-sub-section immediately above, as I have in (6)* an extra term for ∂[∂(t): E0] at right angles to Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo)), due to angular changes. However, it's hard to tell given the term EIpds(POIo(t),t)/Rpcs(POIo(t),t). By applying Lenz's Law : From "Lenz's Induction Law and it's context" based on Lucas p70h0.85 Equation (4-31) : /%(4-31) EIpds(POIo(t),t)*Rpch(POIo(t),t) = -λ(Vons(PART))*E0ods(POIo)*Rpch(POIo(t),t) and therefore : EIpds(POIo(t),t) = -λ(Vons(PART))*E0ods(POIo) From "E0odv(POIp(t),t) = E0pdv(POIp)" : (1)* E0pdv(POIp) = E0odv(POIp(t),t) = Q(PART)/Rpcs(POIp)^2*Rpch(POIp) Subbing (1)* into (4-31)* : (4-31) EIpds(POIo(t),t)*Rpch(POIo(t),t) = -λ(Vons(PART))*E0ods(POIo)*Rpch(POIo(t),t) (1) = -λ(Vons(PART))*Q(PART)/Rpcs(POIp)^2*Rpch(POIo(t),t) Subbing (1) into (6)* : ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))^2*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 - EIpds(POIo(t),t)/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))^2*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 - (-λ(Vons(PART))*Q(PART)/Rpcs(POIp)^2)/Rpcs(POIo(t),t) - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } /*Do I have a mistake with the sign here? /*Summarizing to yield Howell's expression Section "∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] subbing for Lenz's Law : /%(2) ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))^2*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *[1 + λ(Vons(PART))/3] - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } /*Substituting for lambda from Lucas p73h0.7 in the text : /% lambda = β^2 = (Vons(PART)/c)^2 /*+-----+ REPEATING results for ease of comparison : From Lucas (4-16), sub-sub-section above : /%(3) ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *Rθ0ocs(POIo)/Rθ0pcs(POIo(t),t) - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } /*Howell's expression Section "∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] subbing for Lenz's Law : /%(2) ∂[∂(t): BTpdv(POIo(t),t)] = ∂[∂(t): BTodv(POIo,t)] = Vons(PART)^2/c*sin(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))^2*cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t))*Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo(t),t)) *{ 3*Q(PART) /Rpcs(POIo(t),t)^3 *[1 + λ(Vons(PART))/3] - ∂[∂(t): EIpds(POIo(t),t)]/Vons(PART)/cos(Aθpc(POIo(t),t)) } /*These are "somewhat similar", and the factor of 3 is explained. However, there are very important differences, as highlighted above. As for the cause of the discrepancy, that is not fully clear : As per above "... While the factor of 3 IS EXPLAINED, this is NOT the same as (3) in the sub-sub-section immediately above, as I have in (6)* an extra term for ∂[∂(t): E0] at right angles to Rodh(Vonv_X_Rpcv(POIo)), due to angular changes. ..." perhaps there is also a difference between point-particle and finite-sized derivations, as I have not yet done the latter? But this is not obvious from Lucas' book.